Consider the scale that you will find in a produce department. When fruit is placed on it gently, the scale will read true. If the same fruit were to be dropped from even a small height on to the same scale, the needle will jump significantly more than the true mass.
This is a real-world example that allows most of my clients to understand that generally, for strength gains while lifting weights, momentum is a silent killer. Imagine how much force your joints (including ligaments, bursa, etc) take when swinging weights around. The acceleration involved in most peoples techniqie is likely worse for them than the exercise is good.
So why do we do these techniques and why are so many trainers teaching them? In my opinion, it comes down to two things: firstly, a lack of real science in the majority of exercise, and secondly, people see certain results doing it that way.
Science has to be based on more than "that's the way I was taught." It must be done with thought and consideration past our norm or status quo. Science must be measurable, testable and repeatable. It would be near impossible to repeat the force necessary to swing the Tibia upward in an uncontrolled Leg Extension motion. Although if someone is moving the entire stack of weights, I can almost guarantee that there is no control or intent on certain muscles.
However, the results are there, aren't they? Those beefy guys with massive pipes and the girls with firm behinds are well known to not always have the best form during exercise. Consider that the unmeasurable acceleration and deceleration forces that are applied to their muscles during a "swinging" style are much more massive than if the forces are controlled and smooth. More force on a muscle means more tearing of the fibers, giving us big, quick gains. More force also tends to mean more injuries or long-term (often irreversible) joint damage.
Verbally cueing clients while they perform movements is a key component to them getting an effective and safe workout. When trying to get people to achieve a controlled motion with or without resistance in the gym, I say words like "smooth," "tight," "squeeze," and "control." These words give the idea that we don't jump in to a motion or jerk it to a stop. When the exercise begins and ends with an engaged target muscle (or group of muscles) and no sudden jumps, I know that whatever mass they are moving is translating directly to where we mean it to be.
The opposite can be seen when doing any sort of power lifting maneuver. For example, the notorious Bench Press. Most of us can picture the bar being dropped toward the chest, caught, and shoved back up as hard as possible. It's a valid technique when trying to press as much mass as possible. On the other hand, it does not allow for a precise load to be applied to any specific muslce. If a client needs to engage and strengthen pec major, we have to slow down and control that same bench press motion to be sure they they are using pec major the entire time.
Really what we can describe the two schools as are Internal and External motivations. Internal motivation implies that we are paying attention to what the body feels like. External motivation implies that the focus is on how much weight, what the exercise makes us look like, or anything of the sort. I can't say that External Motivation is wrong, it is simply another way of (in this case) performing exercise. For my purposes of making clients stronger, decreasing the risk of injuries, rehabilitating injuries, or general exercise education - Internal Motivation is the way to go.
Jordan McWhirter, BKin, FMS, TPI, RTS, Kinesio Taping
No comments:
Post a Comment